• You are viewing the forum as a Guest, please login (you can use your Facebook, Twitter, Google or Microsoft account to login) or register using this link: Log in or Sign Up

Paint reflector in white ?

eminor

Member
Joined
5 Feb 2021
Messages
784
Location
France
Hello i have an odyssera fixture which have some kind of parabolic reflector which seems not that good, i have the idea to paint it in white, is white paint really better ? thx

reflector looks like this


odyssea-4-tubes-T5HO-lighting-with-leds-24-60cm-Quad-Aquarium-Lighting-4X24W-6500k-for-plant.jpg
 
In what sense is it not good? Seems to me the reflector has a silver polish which will reflect more light than plain white which will absorb some of the light.
Actually that isn't really true, well for some white paints..
aluminum..black line

webview


White paint..
Vis-NIR-reflectance-spectra-of-Pigment-Red-179-dispersions-over-white-a-and-black-b.png

Probably splitting hairs her though..


Extra special white paint:

Anyways about the orig. post..
Would not recommend white paint soo close to even that cool of a bulb.
Latex paints are plastics basically.

Next if you do use white paint add Barium sulfate.
 
Last edited:
Hello i have an odyssera fixture which have some kind of parabolic reflector which seems not that good, i have the idea to paint it in white, is white paint really better ? thx

reflector looks like this


View attachment 185515
On a more practical level you could possibly replace that sheet reflector w/ ind reflectors.
Greenhouse suppliers or hydroponic stores may have something..
T5 reflector ATI | T5 / T8 reflectors | Lighting

Main problem is more of geometry than material..

Try to find something like this and see if it fits..

SunBlaster NanoTech T5 Reflector​

 
Last edited:
Actually that isn't really true, well for some white paints..
aluminum..black line

webview


White paint..
Reflectance-spectra-of-the-different-paint-color-treatments-The-colors-used-to-paint.png


Extra special white paint:

Anyways about the orig. post..
Would not recommend white paint soo close to even that cool of a bulb.
Latex paints are plastics basically.

Next if you do use white paint add Barium sulfate.
That graph doesn't tell me much. It's pretty generic. What's the source of that? What exactly is white paint here? There are literally thousands of white paints, the exceedingly large majority of which will have inferior reflectance compared to designed reflectors made of aluminium or other highly reflective materials.
 
Going back to my orig article..
baso4.JPG

And this..
mirrorsfigure5.jpg


Lets just say they are pretty equal "as is".
White better with more Ba Sulfate added.

Spectralon is basically "Teflon"

I can find better and worse al charts..Mylar sucks btw in comparison..
alchart.JPG



soo we have "some" aluminums, "some" whites..


Getting past this diversion.. as I said their problem wasn't the "color" but the geometry of the reflector.
 
Last edited:
Mylar sucks btw in comparison..
Allow me to take that statement coming from a company that produces a competing reflective film product as not being entirely partial. But let's say for a second it does suck.
I am not expert in light, but I think there is a good reason why companies use aluminium or equivalent reflectors made of non white color. Cost perhaps? Now, will engineered white paints or white reflective material reflect better, maybe. But realistically speaking the OP is simply asking if he should paint his reflector in white and the chances that he uses a specifically designed product that will reflect light better are probably infinitesimal small. The assumption here is that he would use the old plain wall or spray paint which I don't see that reflecting light any better, most probably reflecting it worse. Hence my first comment. Just my opinion. I could be wrong.
 
Allow me to take that statement coming from a company that produces a competing reflective film product as not being entirely partial. But let's say for a second it does suck.
I am not expert in light, but I think there is a good reason why companies use aluminium or equivalent reflectors made of non white color. Cost perhaps? Now, will engineered white paints or white reflective material reflect better, maybe. But realistically speaking the OP is simply asking if he should paint his reflector in white and the chances that he uses a specifically designed product that will reflect light better are probably infinitesimal small. The assumption here is that he would use the old plain wall or spray paint which I don't see that reflecting light any better, most probably reflecting it worse. Just my opinion. I could be wrong.
Right, like I stated.. it was the geomoetry of the reflector not the substance.
Sorry the white thing is a tangent I probably shouldn't have ventured on..

As to companies.. well a white finish, even if better than polished aluminum probably won't look very good after awhile and maintenance is more difficult. Think chipping paint ect.
Certainly easier to clean and polish than white Ba laced paint. :)
To use something even better than both.. teflon coated reflectors would be prohibitively costly.

Industry RARELY uses "the best" just the most practical.. and then markets the heck out of it.
The vid you posted (only scanned it) shows about the difference between flat white and "the best" is about 10%
10% of 1000 "PAR" is 100.. Think there is much difference in growth between 1000 and 900 PAR?
Some crops maybe, some not so much.

Cannabis is a LIGHT HOG and can take par far exceeding what other plants could tolerate in the long run.
Even then probably splitting hairs.

Compare Grow Room Wall Coverings: Mylar vs. White Paint vs. Vinyl GrowWall™

BTW: Don't agree with his numbers as to Mylar and paint but the text is interesting..

PET films are "mylar"
Keep in mind it is an advertising blurb.. ;)
The chart below demonstrates the reflectance vs. wavelength performance of several popular brands and materials used in hydroponic grow rooms. Metalized Polyethylene Terephthalate Film was first developed by DuPont in the 1950's; originally branded as Mylar, it is now commonly known as PET film and manufactured all over the world. Many products in the hydroponic industry are associated with false or misleading performance claims, and this is true of reflective films. PET film products are marketed to hydroponic consumers with performance claims as high as 99% reflectivity, despite historically testing in the low to upper 80% reflectance range in the visible spectrum.(More)
chart.jpg

baso4-jpg.jpg

BTW: ORCA is white..
 
Last edited:
Oh oh I missed something important. The paint chart above looks to be relative to spectralon NOT actual light spectrum.
Bonehead move on my part . Fortunately it only means 100% is 99% which is why Ba alone can archive the impossible of > 100% reflection. Adjust accordingly `
600px-Reflectance-spectrum-of-Spectralon.png


Lastly about MIRO Silver reflectors..
Addendum. 86-90% is the reflectance of TiO2 in white paint
 
Last edited:
Going back to @eminor picture with those lights looks strong enough
thanks guys, i wasn't expecting that much information, i think i'm entering the rabbit hole with not enough light. tuberculatum might drive me crazy haha.

Clive would tell me to keep focus on co2, even with good diffusion, levels (drop checker yellow) tuberculatum seems to need tons of light

Maybe i'll let the reflector like that but i think it's not the most effective, or perhaps i'll upgrade with hydro reflectors as suggested above
 
In all honesty I don't think you need to. Seems more like an excuse to spend more money but it won't solve your issue with Myriophyllum tuberculatum unless your tank is super tall. What's the size of that tank?
60*30*30

Light : 2 * t5 HO, 24 watts, bulb 1 : sylvania 830 14w (overdrive), bulb 2 ; Amtra (wave) special plant pink 24w, the fixture is on the top of the tank
 
60*30*30

Light : 2 * t5 HO, 24 watts, bulb 1 : sylvania 830 14w (overdrive), bulb 2 ; Amtra (wave) special plant pink 24w, the fixture is on the top of the tank
That seems more than plenty considering your tank is 30cm high.
Maybe i need to work better to avoid shadow, that plant seems to won't allow shadow
Yes more like it. Plant it somewhere straight under the light where no other plants will shaddow it. It should grow fast. I have to trim mine weekly. It grows ~15/20cm in a week.
 
I have these on my T5 tubes.
T5 Reflectors – iQuatics

In my use, the advantages are scale from hardwater doesn't stick and when the reflective bit degrades you can just buy new inserts.

Before I used quite expensive aluminium reflectors, but suffered from scale severely reducing efficiency and slow but sure changing from super shiny aluminium to misty/brown/frosted metal reflector. Really really obvious in light levels when I changed from old aluminium to the iQuatics ones.
 
LOL should have started with size. 12" deep tank w/ volume est of 15 gallons shouldn' t have a light issue w/ 100 watts of light regardless of reflector efficiency.
As to Myro, I' ve grown it like a weed and also killed it easily

It is not an easy plant to cultivate. The M. Tuberculatum needs intensive light of at least 0.8 watts per liter, and high levels of CO2 injection. Nitrates should be kept to between 5 - 15 mg/l, and phosphates to between 1 - 2 mg/l. If either of these main nutrients falls below zero, the plant’s growth will be severely stunted. The species also need plenty of iron and micronutrients to reach its full size and color, or else it will end up as a dark and small plant
 
Last edited:
LOL should have started with size. 12" deep tank w/ volume est of 15 gallons shouldn' t have a light issue w/ 100 watts of light regardless of reflector efficiency.
As to Myro, I' ve grown it like a weed and also killed it easily
Sorry i'm French, i still have some issue to understand english sometimes, you mean that even without reflector, i have more than enought light due to the small height of the tank ?
 
Sorry i'm French, i still have some issue to understand english sometimes, you mean that even without reflector, i have more than enought light due to the small height of the tank ?
Even with your current reflector you should have more than enough light.
2 x 39w Odyssea par values (36" fixture)
10.5" (26 cm)130 91 92 85
16" (41cm) - 86 53 63 59.
Not apples to apples comparison but it paints a picture.
Measured in free air.
I assume light face to surface.
 
Back
Top