Maloney
Member
Hi, I have a male Golden Cockatoo Cichlid, he's pretty big ,around 4", could I introduce a female so they could may pair up?
-
You are viewing the forum as a Guest, please login (you can use your Facebook, Twitter, Google or Microsoft account to login) or register using this link: Log in or Sign Up
Apistogramma
- Thread starter Maloney
- Start date
clonitza
Member
Hi Maloney, yes you can, you could've done that earlier. You don't need to add more than 1 female. The cockatoo females are territorial, they are the one who raise the fry not the male so if you have plenty and not so many space for them they'll keep on fighting. Hope you are not keeping them in the 30l tank.
Mike
Mike
Hi all,
He might be a bit old all ready, as the males don't live very long. If you have a lot of structure they are fine as a pair, if the tank is a bit open the male will continually harass the female when she isn't ready to breed and may kill her (although this isn't usually a problem with A. cacatuoides). They are naturally harem forming and if you have enough room I'd try 3 females, you need an approx. 30 cm x 30cm square around each cave per female.
I've never had much luck with 2 females, as the dominant one always beats up the sub-dominant female, but once you have 3 females things are fine.
cheers Darrel
He might be a bit old all ready, as the males don't live very long. If you have a lot of structure they are fine as a pair, if the tank is a bit open the male will continually harass the female when she isn't ready to breed and may kill her (although this isn't usually a problem with A. cacatuoides). They are naturally harem forming and if you have enough room I'd try 3 females, you need an approx. 30 cm x 30cm square around each cave per female.
I've never had much luck with 2 females, as the dominant one always beats up the sub-dominant female, but once you have 3 females things are fine.
cheers Darrel
clonitza
Member
Darrel, I'm sure the males would like having as many females as possible, that's the nature of things 
but from my experience as an cockatoo keeper and breeder they do just fine in pairs. He tries doing his thing now and then but if the female isn't ready the male doesn't really stand a chance. Anyway sometimes you may have bad luck keeping an aggressive male, it happened to me once and I had to remove it to solve the problem.
Cheers,
Mike
but from my experience as an cockatoo keeper and breeder they do just fine in pairs. He tries doing his thing now and then but if the female isn't ready the male doesn't really stand a chance. Anyway sometimes you may have bad luck keeping an aggressive male, it happened to me once and I had to remove it to solve the problem. Cheers,
Mike
Hi all,
Mike I'm not disagreeing, A. cacatuoides does fine as a pair, mainly because they are pretty mellow for cichlids. I've kept them as every combination from pair through to 7 females and one male (If I'd had a bigger tank I could have kept some more females ). I've also had 4 sub-adult males and several females in the same tank (60cm x 45 x 30cm) for a while although the males were all siblings.
I'd have to say they are my favourite fish, partially because they fund my hobby, and I have them in a tank in the kitchen, so I get to see them every day.
Out of the species I've kept pairs don't work with A. trifasciata or A. "Steel-blue", because the males are much more aggressive and you can keep A. borellii as multiple males/females successfully, even in a 60cm tank.
Here is an old female, she lived to 4 years old, none of the males have lived anything like that long (male is face on to the left of the picture).
cheers Darrel
Mike I'm not disagreeing, A. cacatuoides does fine as a pair, mainly because they are pretty mellow for cichlids. I've kept them as every combination from pair through to 7 females and one male (If I'd had a bigger tank I could have kept some more females ). I've also had 4 sub-adult males and several females in the same tank (60cm x 45 x 30cm) for a while although the males were all siblings.
I'd have to say they are my favourite fish, partially because they fund my hobby, and I have them in a tank in the kitchen, so I get to see them every day.
Out of the species I've kept pairs don't work with A. trifasciata or A. "Steel-blue", because the males are much more aggressive and you can keep A. borellii as multiple males/females successfully, even in a 60cm tank.
Here is an old female, she lived to 4 years old, none of the males have lived anything like that long (male is face on to the left of the picture).
cheers Darrel
Hi all,
Just nostalgia really, but I just found another photo, this was "Troy" (the kids named him). He wasn't my first Apistogramma, but he started my "Apistogramma empire", and I must admit I cried when he died (I think he was just knackered as he had the 7 female harem and had fathered hundreds of fry).
He didn't have very good finnage colour or markings, but he was a very good body colour, had a very placid temperament and was a really powerful chunky fish.
cheers Darrel
Just nostalgia really, but I just found another photo, this was "Troy" (the kids named him). He wasn't my first Apistogramma, but he started my "Apistogramma empire", and I must admit I cried when he died (I think he was just knackered as he had the 7 female harem and had fathered hundreds of fry).
He didn't have very good finnage colour or markings, but he was a very good body colour, had a very placid temperament and was a really powerful chunky fish.
cheers Darrel
clonitza
Member
Great looking fellows Darrel. I enjoy keeping them too, although I miss the rams.
Here's a pic with my one year old male:
one of the little ones
and the female guarding the eggs
Cheers,
Mike
Here's a pic with my one year old male:
one of the little ones
and the female guarding the eggs
Cheers,
Mike
cichlidfam
Member
Great shots guys,
Heres some of my F1 fry
And heres there daddy, sadly in fish heaven.
Excuse quality on first two pics as i'm waiting for my lens to come back from repair.
Matt
Heres some of my F1 fry
And heres there daddy, sadly in fish heaven.
Excuse quality on first two pics as i'm waiting for my lens to come back from repair.
Matt
Maloney
Member
Thanks for the info , all the apistogramma females Ihave seen are a lot smaller than him ,would he be ok with a small female? also does the female have to be of the same sub species? ie a Golden ?
cichlidfam
Member
Females are naturally alot smaller, and yes i'm pretty sure you can mix i.e a tripple red male and a golden female etc.
Hi all,
This is one that Steve Chesters (from the BCA) had, wild and imported from Peru.
The female will always be a fair bit smaller than the male, this is actually a pretty good clue to whether cichlids are pair forming or naturally polygamous (male/females harem). If they are pairt forming like Hemichromis,Rams, Oscars, Angel Fish etc the male and female tend to look similar and be of a similar size, if they are haremic the male tends to be a lot bigger and showier than the females.
If the female isn't ready to breed it would be worth putting a piece of pipe high up in one corner of the tank, to give her somewhere safe to retreat to. If an Apistogramma spends a lot of time near the top of the tank, it is because it doesn't feel safe at lower levels. If she is really small a 35mm filnm canister works quite well.
I also use 1/2 coconuts for this, you can cut a very small notch in the rim, and the female will be able to enter, but not the male. They cover really quickly with moss if you super-glue some on, so they can be intergrated into the aquascaping unless it is a very bare tank (if it is very bare your cichlids aren't going to feel safe what-ever you do).
cheers Darrel
This is right, all the colour forms of A. cacatuoides are just that, colour forms. Apistogramma cacatuoides is a polychromatic species and breeders have selected for the red, orange and leucistic forms. I really like the blue/yellow forms, but they aren't often for sale.
The female will always be a fair bit smaller than the male, this is actually a pretty good clue to whether cichlids are pair forming or naturally polygamous (male/females harem). If they are pairt forming like Hemichromis,Rams, Oscars, Angel Fish etc the male and female tend to look similar and be of a similar size, if they are haremic the male tends to be a lot bigger and showier than the females.
If the female isn't ready to breed it would be worth putting a piece of pipe high up in one corner of the tank, to give her somewhere safe to retreat to. If an Apistogramma spends a lot of time near the top of the tank, it is because it doesn't feel safe at lower levels. If she is really small a 35mm filnm canister works quite well.
I also use 1/2 coconuts for this, you can cut a very small notch in the rim, and the female will be able to enter, but not the male. They cover really quickly with moss if you super-glue some on, so they can be intergrated into the aquascaping unless it is a very bare tank (if it is very bare your cichlids aren't going to feel safe what-ever you do).
cheers Darrel
I have kept a pair successfully in my planted tank, as its already been stressed having lots of hiding places really helps, once a planted tank is well grown these tend to provide an ideal environment. Here are a couple of pics of my Apistogramma Agassizii 'fire red', which have become one of my favourite fish.
Pair of Apistogramma Agassizii 'fire red' by andyh_2011, on Flickr
Apistogramma Agassizii 'fire red' by andyh_2011, on Flickr
Interesting thread this one
Pair of Apistogramma Agassizii 'fire red' by andyh_2011, on Flickr
Apistogramma Agassizii 'fire red' by andyh_2011, on Flickr
Interesting thread this one
Hi all,
I've just seen the full-tank shot on flickr (June 22,"fulltank shot 2") and that looks really nice, and about right for a planted Apistogramma tank.
cheers Darrel
They look in great condition, do they spawn? I must admit that I'm not usually a fan of unnatural looking Discus etc, but you can't argue about these being a striking pair.
I've just seen the full-tank shot on flickr (June 22,"fulltank shot 2") and that looks really nice, and about right for a planted Apistogramma tank.
cheers Darrel
