• You are viewing the forum as a Guest, please login (you can use your Facebook, Twitter, Google or Microsoft account to login) or register using this link: Log in or Sign Up

Decreasing pH and hardness

idris

Member
Joined
3 Jan 2011
Messages
816
Location
Herts
I'm vaguely thinking about trying to reduce the pH and hardness of water in my tank so I can keep fish that prefer softer, more acidic water. It's a while since I read up on this sort of thing, but from what I remember I could use peat to simultaneously reduce pH and hardness.

I think my best option for doing this is by using a bag (or stocking) of aquatic peat in the filter.

Have I remembered this correctly, and are there any other considerations, like speed of such changes in water chemistry, or the effects on established plants and/or existing livestock?
 
I think some shops do peat balls that are measured to give you the right amount of peat for a certain amount of water. Bearing in mind that peat will cause a black water effect, but I think amazon fish quite like that! There are also comercial PH products that can make it go up or down but these might not be sufficient. Hope this helps!:)
 
Peat has a negligible effect on pH and hardness unless your tap water is fairly soft already. IME the only way to reliably lower the pH and hardness in a plant and fish friendly way is to use water with a lower GH and KH - ie. RO water.
 
I agree with Ed. Trust me I have asked this question many times and it all boils down to RO.
 
RO is the only way. But bear in mind that RO is neutral until it has something disolved in it to change the pH. So if you add RO to alkaline water your still going to have alkaline water. If your using CO2 that will help lower the pH a bit but once you add the RO you will have to have something in there to lower the pH - like a peat ball or specific minieral salts or one of the pH down products.
 
RO + soil substrate (Aqua Soil, NutraSoil etc.) is probably the most effective way to achieve soft and acidic water with a stable pH. There's a reason keepers and breeders of delicate softwater fish and shrimp swear by it.

Using any products in an attempt to soften/acidify mineral-rich water is futile, with the exception of using a soil substrate.
 
I haven't tested the water recently and my test kit is probably past it's use-by date by now. The pH used to be about 7.4: I can't remember what GH and KH were I'm afraid, but I know they were relatively high. (We live in a chalk stream area.)

I've looked at RO before but, for various reasons, of that's the only option I'll probably not bother.

Peat as a substrate isn't an easy option either as it will mean a complete overhaul of an awkwardly deep and 'scaped tank. (Not something I have the time or energy for.) I could replace a little of my Adakama without too much hassle, but probably only about a litre (in a 250l tank).

George - Is there any reason why something like Aquasoil in the filter wouldn't work?
 
George - Fair point on soil break down.
I want to get some Killifish. The cognocenti seem to think they need soft, acidic water, but I don't know how neccessary that really is.

Tubamanandy - I was under the impression that de-ionising filters just replaced one sort of salts with another sort. Or am I thinking of something else?
 
All I know is I dont have particularly hard water but at certain times of the year, I pre-filter my water through a simple pod filled with de-ionising resin and the TDS drops very significantly (RO water would clearly be better)
 
Tubamanandy - I was under the impression that de-ionising filters just replaced one sort of salts with another sort. Or am I thinking of something else?
Correct, usually use to remove the left over trace calcium ions from RO membrane with either sodium or potassium ions. Unless you have a whole house water softener which replaces all the hard calcium with soft sodium, but then no good for fish.
 
Back
Top