Eco complete

MrWhite

Newly Registered
Joined
27 Apr 2009
Messages
9
Ive read and also seen in londondragons journal that aquasoil clouds water when its disturb and basically turns to mud after so long is this the same case with eco complete because i wanna buy this stuff but if thats the case then i will just buy something else

thanks
 

ceg4048

Expert/Global Moderator
Staff member
Joined
11 Jul 2007
Messages
8,955
Location
Chicago, USA
Hi,
Aquasoil I is the superior product in terms of nutrient availability. Many of the clouding complaints are associated with AS II. EC is a decent substrate and does not have a clouding issue, but also does not contain NPK, only some traces. This is much more important than the inconvenience of a little clouding. If you dose the water column then AS's higher nutrient content is less of an advantage. All things being equal, AS is the better choice, really.

Cheers,
 

Themuleous

Member
Joined
6 Jul 2007
Messages
4,124
Location
Aston, Oxfordshire
Iv just swapped the clay substrate in my 4ft for eco-complete pretty much for this reason. EC is a good substrate better than most out there, although as Ceg says AS is the superior product.

Sam
 

MrWhite

Newly Registered
Joined
27 Apr 2009
Messages
9
Think i will go for eco complete then thanks guys so eco complete doesn't turn to mud then ?
 

JohnC

Member
Joined
14 Nov 2008
Messages
1,069
Location
On a mountain in the Highlands of Scotland
Hi,

I've used EC on my main tank for over a year now. I like it but there are a couple of issues.

1. Variable grain size. You can get bags that are much larger then others in grain size. Even within one bag you can get some large grains in with it. I ended up sieving it for use in my nanos.

2. I did find some of my stems when i had them and some crypts wanted more root feeding and used some tabs. But it may have also been inaccurate water column dosing by me, so i'd seek other verification on that opinion.

It was my first substrate post gravel and inert sand so i can give any comparable reports. I am going to try other things on my nanos when I rescape them (tis the reason i'm in this forum area right now :D ).

Best Regards,
John
 
Top