UP atomiser vs. Boyu inline?

Alastair

Member
Joined
27 Dec 2009
Messages
4,404
Location
Denton, Manchester
I have tried both and found them both equally as efficient, the boyu doesn't give you the smokey must effect close up, just tiny bubbles. I actually preferred this one.
I also gave one to eazerthegeezer whilst he used one of each and I think he liked it too. It's much much cheaper too the boyu but does give a little faint hiss when it's on


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

Ady34

Global Moderator
Staff member
Joined
27 Jul 2011
Messages
4,611
Location
Co. Durham
H there,
Just to add to the above although I haven't used the up inline I do run a boyu.
If found it to be very good, but the hiss is quite loud so if it's not running in a cabinet it will be annoying. Mine is in an undertank cabinet and I can't hear it with the doors closed.
Also I only run at 1.5 bar pressure and it works fine, I've heard the up ones need upwards of 2 bar running pressure so this could also be something to take into consideration depending on your working pressures.
Cheerio
Ady
 

nry

Member
Joined
23 Oct 2007
Messages
1,227
Location
Cumbria, UK
I've got a Boyu at present, but I don't find the bubbles overly small - managed to find an UP one via eBay for £16 delivered (12/16mm) which is on the way now so I'll soon know if I have a preference! I have to admit to never cleaning the Boyu one as the piping is zip-tied to the ends. The UP one has a better fitment so it my stand more chance of being maintained correctly :)
 

Ady34

Global Moderator
Staff member
Joined
27 Jul 2011
Messages
4,611
Location
Co. Durham
It's funny because I ran my boyu on the filter outlet last time round and the bubbles were tiny coming into the tank. This time round I've opted for the filter inlet and I get even better misting but when I switched the filter off the other day I noticed that the bubbles coming back into the tank were huge
(drilled base so bubbles rose directly back up into the tank), this suggests that the water flow itself inside the pipes breaks down the larger bubbles into mist.....unless of course mine has clogged too. Either way on the filter inlet I'm getting good misting :thumbup:
Cheerio
Ady
 

John S

Member
Joined
13 Dec 2008
Messages
853
Location
Welwyn Garden City
Ady34 said:
It's funny because I ran my boyu on the filter outlet last time round and the bubbles were tiny coming into the tank. This time round I've opted for the filter inlet and I get even better misting but when I switched the filter off the other day I noticed that the bubbles coming back into the tank were huge
(drilled base so bubbles rose directly back up into the tank), this suggests that the water flow itself inside the pipes breaks down the larger bubbles into mist.....unless of course mine has clogged too. Either way on the filter inlet I'm getting good misting :thumbup:
Cheerio
Ady
Ady, not wishing to take this off track but, did you notice any difference in CO2 usage, or bubble rate, when swapping to the inlet from the outlet? I'm just about to swap from outlet to inlet.
 

Ady34

Global Moderator
Staff member
Joined
27 Jul 2011
Messages
4,611
Location
Co. Durham
davem said:
Ady34 said:
It's funny because I ran my boyu on the filter outlet last time round and the bubbles were tiny coming into the tank. This time round I've opted for the filter inlet and I get even better misting but when I switched the filter off the other day I noticed that the bubbles coming back into the tank were huge
(drilled base so bubbles rose directly back up into the tank), this suggests that the water flow itself inside the pipes breaks down the larger bubbles into mist.....unless of course mine has clogged too. Either way on the filter inlet I'm getting good misting :thumbup:
Cheerio
Ady
Ady, not wishing to take this off track but, did you notice any difference in CO2 usage, or bubble rate, when swapping to the inlet from the outlet? I'm just about to swap from outlet to inlet.
Hi mate, not as yet as I just tested it the other day, it's not actually running yet but it'll be something to monitor. Unfortunately it won't be easy to compare as I'm going to be running more surface agitation and no cover glass this time round so gas off will be greater anyway.
Cheerio
Ady
 

John S

Member
Joined
13 Dec 2008
Messages
853
Location
Welwyn Garden City
Thanks for the reply :thumbup:

I will do a search on here to see what I can find. I'd imagine a few have tried both on the same set up.
 

Ady34

Global Moderator
Staff member
Joined
27 Jul 2011
Messages
4,611
Location
Co. Durham
The benefit of running pre filter is longer contact time so in theory gas exchange should be more efficient thus you should use less....but as we all know should and do are two very different things in the planted tank world :crazy:
 
Top