What is this?

Discussion in 'Plant Help' started by Murphy-18, 19 Mar 2009.

  1. Murphy-18

    Murphy-18 Member

    Hi could somebody ID this for me if possible please. Cheers. :) Its only couple inches high and wide. Picture079.jpg
  2. Steve Smith

    Steve Smith Member

    Leamington Spa, UK.
    Looks like some sort of lilly, like a nymphaea tiger lotus or something :)
  3. vauxhallmark

    vauxhallmark Member

    It's a piranha.

  4. Joecoral

    Joecoral Member

    Neath, South Wales
    Just when you thought it was safe to go back into the water....
  5. gratts

    gratts Member

    Looks more like a big rock to me.
  6. Murphy-18

    Murphy-18 Member

    I don't think it is a Tiger lotus, ive had it for a good few weeks now and there has been no real growth out of it. I wanna keep it though cos i know it will be a cool looking plant if it grows. Anybody got any ideas?

    Appreciated folks
  7. Ed Seeley

    Ed Seeley Member

    Nymphaea 'rubra'. I've put it in quotes as I've seen it sold as a number of things including N.stellata and not sure of the correct name. IME it grows well for a while and then goes dormant and I've always struggled to get it going again.
  8. Murphy-18

    Murphy-18 Member

    Cheers Ed :)
  9. Murphy-18

    Murphy-18 Member

    One more question.

    Is there anything else i could to imrpove its growth? I have 1.3 wpg and dose 1 capful of flourish excel daily. Would you reccomend adding anything else, i really dont wanna start a co2 setup.

    Thankd again.
  10. mjenner

    mjenner Member

    Chessington, Surrey
    Hi Murphy,

    I've got one of these left over from my old tank before I tore it down ready to restart a new scape (not sure of the exact species, it was from Java Plants, think it was a Tiger Lily or something like that, this was before I paid attention to plant names too much). It used to grow like a weed, it looked a little like yours when I first got it, I don't think they like being moved about and seem to sulk for a while before they start to grow.

    It was in a low-tech tank (though partial neglect and partial lack of knowledge): monthly-ish water changes, 3x 20w T8's, heavily planted, a fair bit of accumulated mulm. As a result of the light, it reached for the surface and it's leaves became massive, but it did look really impressive but tended to take over, so I think it can survive without additional CO2 ok! :)

    Every so often I used to prune it when it was getting silly (snipping the leaves off near the base) I'd take off about 4-5 tea-saucer to side-plate sized leaves! The guppy fry loved them though as it gave them a safe place to hide.

    About that time I read that if you kept cutting the leaves off before they reached the surface it'd start to produce smaller leaves that would stay submerged for longer, so I started to get more vigorous with my pruning.

    It split into 2 or 3 plants during that time. I took one of the smaller ones and put it into my little nano-cube when I set it up, thinking it'd provide a bit of colour until the other plants grew in, but under the brighter light (11w over 25l tank) it's not quite such an aggressive grower, it's growing happily submerged. It's leaves did become a bit algified but more recently (since deciding to rescape my main tank and joining this forum) I've begun a campaign of fertilising and adding Flourish Excel to the little cube to see it's effects and algae has almost gone and the leaves are pearling underneath.

    The only thing I'd say is, yes they do have slow and fast growth periods (from my observations) and that I don't think they like to be buried too deeply in the substrate. currently the last 1cm of my lily's roots are all visible above the substrate, it might not like being too deep in the sand.

    Also, older leaves, do tend to melt a bit rot down if they've had the slightest bit of damage, don't worry too much, just snip them off near the base, one problem I get is sucking them with the hose by accident when siphoning. So long as there are new leaves growing from the base you don't have to worry too much.

    Probably best to give it a bit of time, and maybe sweep a bit of the sand off the roots? (based upon my limited experience)



    Anyone else, please feel free to contradict if you know better :)
  11. Murphy-18

    Murphy-18 Member

    Thanks alot for the info, i shall give it sometime and see how it goes.

    Appreciated.. :D

Share This Page

Facebook Page
Twitter Page
  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
    Dismiss Notice