Alternatives for dosing

tgc

Member
Joined
14 Nov 2007
Messages
109
Location
Wirral NW England
I'm looking for what alternatives are out there for getting ferts etc in the water colum without having to do daily doseing, this is due to me working away and can't expect the wife to have to carry on the routein when I'm away.

At the moment i have one of those fert "put in and forget for three months" bags.

Cheers in advance.

Tim
 
Joined
16 Nov 2007
Messages
736
Location
Blackpool
feed your fish well and in excess then you get your NPK sorted. If you have really densely planted tank then that might not be adequate though. However, this all depends a lot on the setup that you might have. It would be useful to know what lighting you've got, what size tank, substrate, dosing regime, water change regime etc etc. The more information available, the more others can advice you on alternative dosing method
 

tgc

Member
Joined
14 Nov 2007
Messages
109
Location
Wirral NW England
Tank is Trigon 350, lighting 125w MV pendant, water changes 20% weekly, sand substrate, and as for ferts one of those afore mentioned bags, oh yes and soon to be pressurised c02.

Cheers Tim
 

Dan Crawford

Founder
Staff member
Joined
21 Jun 2007
Messages
3,266
Location
Daventry, Northants
I believe that you can dose EI once a week.............I dose every other day as per the Nutricalc software so i've not tried it but i believe it to be possible.
 
Joined
16 Nov 2007
Messages
736
Location
Blackpool
With an inert substrate like sand, It's best to go with EI dosing. There is no nutrient provided by the sand so the plants will not grow well if you depends on fish waste to feed your plants. Over feeding the fish in this case will only lead to sufficient amount of NPK in the water column but lack in micros and trace element.
 

ceg4048

Expert/Global Moderator
Staff member
Joined
11 Jul 2007
Messages
8,955
Location
Chicago, USA
tgc said:
Tank is Trigon 350, lighting 125w MV pendant, water changes 20% weekly, sand substrate, and as for ferts one of those afore mentioned bags, oh yes and soon to be pressurised c02.

Cheers Tim
Hi Tim,
I guess I'm not really sure how many gallons a Trigon 350 is. 350 litres maybe? If that's the case your lighting is only around 1.4 WPG which is low enough light that a once a week dosing is all you need to be doing anyway. If you're now going to add CO2 then about 15ppm CO2 is all you'd need. Add a bit more ferts that's all, I figure. I don't see any cause for concern unless I've miscalculated and if a Trigon 350 is actually only 35 litres.. :lol:


Cheers,
 

tgc

Member
Joined
14 Nov 2007
Messages
109
Location
Wirral NW England
Yeah 350 ltrs :D

Just started with the pressurised c02, so you say 15ppm should be ok?

At the moment I'm only looking to keep different variaties of moss.

Thanks for all the advice so far..... just been reading Tom Barr's EI write-up :? straight over my head at the moment but I shall keep going and just keep reading it over and over until it sinks in.

Cheers Tim
 

ceg4048

Expert/Global Moderator
Staff member
Joined
11 Jul 2007
Messages
8,955
Location
Chicago, USA
Yes, 15ppm ought to be fine for starters but what's more important as, it's been pointed out in other threads is that the CO2 is stable and that it doesn't wander up and down during the photoperiod. Check the CO2 article in the Cookbook section. That's mostly aimed at highly lit tanks but the same principles apply for low light.

If you have trouble interpreting Barr's info you can ask and we can try to clarify for you. 8)

Cheers,
 

tgc

Member
Joined
14 Nov 2007
Messages
109
Location
Wirral NW England
Right, just tried to read through Tom Barr report and just ended up bamboozling myself again!

Could someone give me an estimate of how much and of what I should dose for once a week dosing???

Also is it best to use powders for this type of dosing.

Where the bast place to get said powders etc??

Cheers Tim
 

George Farmer

Founder
Staff member
Joined
30 Jun 2007
Messages
7,065
Location
Cambridgeshire
I'd use something like Tropica Plant Nutrition+ for once per week dosing. It already contains NPK and all the traces you'll need.

If you're on a budget then pre-mixing a PMDD+PO4 style solution may work.

It is better to dose little and often though, if possible.

Hopefully JamesC will chime in...
 

ceg4048

Expert/Global Moderator
Staff member
Joined
11 Jul 2007
Messages
8,955
Location
Chicago, USA
tgc said:
Right, just tried to read through Tom Barr report and just ended up bamboozling myself again!

Could someone give me an estimate of how much and of what I should dose for once a week dosing???

Also is it best to use powders for this type of dosing.

Where the bast place to get said powders etc??

Cheers Tim
Check this site for availability of dry ferts or for the Tropica liquids: http://www.aquaessentials.co.uk/

For a low light 350l you could try the following once a week dry salts:

1 teaspoon KNO3
1/4 teaspoon KH2PO4
1/2 teaspoon CSM+B (or 22ml TPN)
1/2 teaspoon GH booster

If you decide to use the TPN+ as George alluded to the dosing instructions are on the label (50ml per 50L of water). This means a single product versus 4 different powders, but cost could be an issue. The dry salts are much cheaper.

These numbers are not written in stone. They are just starting numbers and may need adjusting depending on plant mass, fish mass, lighting etc. Observe the plants and if you see signs of deficiency such as algae, stunted/deformed growth and so forth you can make adjustments.

Cheers,
 

tgc

Member
Joined
14 Nov 2007
Messages
109
Location
Wirral NW England
So, so far its

Mono Potassium Phosphate (KH2P04)
Potassium Nitrate (KN03)
GH Booster
CSM+B (can't find this)

So you think the amounts stated would be ok for heavy stocking (discus), also at the moment I just looking at keep lots of different types of mosses.

Cheers
 

JamesC

Member
Joined
3 Jul 2007
Messages
1,276
Location
Bexley, Kent
I'll throw the cat in amongst the pidgeons. Your lighting is what I'd call pretty low. MV's tend to be raised much higher up than fluorescents so the wpg rule doesn't really work here. I would say you will get more than enough NPK from the fish and food so no need to buy any extra. I presume you mean the Pro Aqua bags. These along with your fish and food should be plenty IMO. If you ditched the Pro Aqua bags then you could dose just normal Tropica Plant Nutrtion as directed on the bottle.

James
 

tgc

Member
Joined
14 Nov 2007
Messages
109
Location
Wirral NW England
I'll throw the cat in amongst the pidgeons. Your lighting is what I'd call pretty low. MV's tend to be raised much higher up than fluorescents so the wpg rule doesn't really work here. I would say you will get more than enough NPK from the fish and food so no need to buy any extra. I presume you mean the Pro Aqua bags. These along with your fish and food should be plenty IMO. If you ditched the Pro Aqua bags then you could dose just normal Tropica Plant Nutrtion as directed on the bottle.

James
The MV lamp height above the water as well as the depth of the tank works out about 30" above substrate.

So if i look to get about 15ppm C02 and just keep the fish well fed, swop the bag for the tropica plant nutrition and increase the amount of water changes we should be ok??
 

JamesC

Member
Joined
3 Jul 2007
Messages
1,276
Location
Bexley, Kent
15 ppm CO2 is good, just keep it stable. Sorry didn't word it too well but the Pro Aqua bags are OK to use and there is no reason to not carry on with them. But if you ran out or fancied a change then Tropica Plant Nutrition could be used instead.

I'd carry on as you are to be honest and see how it goes.

James
 
Top