Pruning - A general guide to plant maintenance

Discussion in 'Tutorials' started by James Flexton, 4 Sep 2007.

  1. James Flexton

    James Flexton Member

    Messages:
    358
    Location:
    Stotfold, Herts/Beds
    Hi there everyone. This is something i have been meaning to write for quite a while but for whatever reason haven't managed it. Reading this months PFK which has just come through my door gave me the push. I thought with so much focus on planted tanks and some fantastic aquascapes appearing in PFK etc then we are sure to see a surge in plant keepers. So i thought a pruning guide might be useful. This post is aimed at new hobbyists as a general guide, for more specialist information on specific plants not mentioned here please ask on the main forum.



    Now when you are serious about keeping a proper planted tank there are two stages you need to think of and one often gets overlooked.

    The first stage is deciding what you want, choosing a style you like, nature, dutch, jungle etc.. Then which plants you want to keep normally based on what looks good coupled with your tanks limitations in terms of light etc. Then you plant it up, fiddle about until it looks right then sit back and admire your creation.

    Unfortunately a week or two later your tank will look rather different. Some plants will have grown nicely, coloured up and spread into the perfect position Others however will have shot to the surface and spread across the tank to the front glass. Some leaved may have deteriorated or browned, algae will inevitably effect something etc..

    qw1.jpg

    Now is the time to prune your tank. This is a simple process and if done correctly will not only instantly improve your overgrown aquascape but will encourage vigorous new growth improving the overall health of your plants.

    Not all plants are pruned in the same way so i have broken them down into generalised sections.

    Stem Plants (eg. Camomba, Ludwigia, Hygrophillia)
    - when dealing with plants that have only one stem simply look at the plant while in the tank and picture where you want the top to be allowing for growing room between pruning sessions. Then roughly measure the length from that point to the tip of the plant.

    Now uproot the plant and measure the same length from the base of the roots and cut through the stem with sharp scissors.

    qw2.jpg

    Retain and replant the top section. i usually plant three stems together with thin stemmed plants as it makes setting them in the substrate a bit easier. Try not to crush the stems when you push through the substrate, dig a hole with your finger and push the stems in the hole.

    qe4.jpg

    normally the bottom portion will regrow albeit looking a bit ugly for a while. you can use these if you are trying to propagate additional stems for the main group. I am doing this now as you see below.

    qe5.jpg

    If you want your stem plants to branch out and fill a larger area then snip off the very top section and new growth will be diverted to side shoots further down the main stem. This is useful when propagating Ludwigia etc..

    Stem Plants are the fastest growing of aquatic plants and will require regular weekly pruning to stay in check.

    Rosette Plants (eg/ Amazon Swords, Lillies etc..)
    These are steady growers, not quite as rapid as stem plants but do still require pruning. Sword Leaves should be removed when the leaf protrudes past the surface or if you see any damaged or dying leaves.

    To remove a leaf just slide your hand down the leaf stem to the crown and gently pull the leaf away from the crown. Do not snap the stem as this will rot and look unsightly. Try to push down on the crown with one finger whilst pulling the leaf with the other finger. You don't want to pull the whole plant from the substrate! When you have removed the leaf you should see a white fleshy bit at the very base of the leaf stem.

    These plants are very good indicators of nutrient deficiencies. When you remove the leaf the following will tell you that you are not supplying enough nutrients to the tank.

    -Glassy Leaves
    -Transparent Veins
    -Brittleness
    -Yellowing

    qe3-1.jpg

    Normally this will be a trace element deficiency (Iron, Potassium, Magnesium etc..)

    Should you need to completely remove and relocate a rosette Plant for any reason take the opportunity to wash the root ball and leaves in old tank water to get all the detritus build up out from the root ball and trim the roots down to 2 to 3 inches. This will encourage new root growth when replanted.

    It is worth mentioning that is a plant has a vast root structure it will therefore demand heavy root feeding for good health. If you do not have a substrate additive like flourite or laterite you way want to add fert sticks or root tabs below the roots before you replant. These species will greatly benefit from such products.

    Rhizome plants (Java fern, Anubias etc..)
    These plants grow with a thick Horizontal stem called a rhizome and are usually attached to wood or rock.

    These plants especially anubias species are particularly prone to spot algae as they are among the slowest growing of aquatic plants.

    qw5.jpg

    You can reduce this problem by shading with other plants but some leaf damage is inevitable. You will therefore need to remove leaves from time to time to maintain a clean look.

    With Java fern follow the leaf down to it's base on the rhizome. Then cut off with scissors (or if your lazy like me use your fingernail) as close to the rhizome as possible.

    qe1-1.jpg

    With Anubias do not use scissors. You will notice the leaves grow in one direction from the main stem. At the leaf base gently bend the leaf back on itself and it will pop free of the rhizome.

    qw6.jpg

    qw7.jpg

    As in rosette plants you will see a white fleshy bit at the base of the detached leaf.

    qw8.jpg

    As these plants normally grow on movable objects i often remove the whole thing from the tank and wash it under the tap and get all the detritus out from deep within the plant leaves and root structure.
    The three specimens below are about 3 years old after planting initially with one inch plantlets from a mother plant. You can imagine the amount of detritus build up these collect over time in the core of the plant. i wash mine every month or so.

    qe2-1.jpg

    Carpeting Plants
    I often see posts with people worrying about vacuuming the substrate when you cant actually see it beneath the plants. This is not a problem as with healthy root growth the roots will slowly move the substrate reducing the chances of dead spots and stripping the substrate of potential pollutants before they build up. As far as cleaning is concerned just wave the gravel vac or syphon tube gently over the top of your carpet. If you have any large messy fish any big poops will be sucked up, the rest beneath the leaves leave alone as this will naturally degrade quite quickly providing nutrients for the roots.

    pfk11.jpg

    Pruning a carpet is not really possible. You can contain it by snipping off stray strands but once it gets too dense it will begin to choke itself and need to be uprooted and replanted. On the positive side you will now have hundreds of plantlets to reseed your next carpet so it wont take very long to fill out again.

    The same is the case with Riccia. You can give it a haircut a few times but in time the new growth will cut out the light to the plantlets lower down the "cushion" causing them to rot and lose their grip on the netting holding it down. In my experience riccia covered slate etc.. has lasted up to 8 weeks before showing signs of falling apart.

    riccialift3.jpg

    Tape Grasses
    (Vallis, Sagittaria etc..)
    These plants are all connected together by horizontal runners at the base of the leaves, they have normal roots on each plantlet but pulling one can result in the whole chain following on so be wary of this when pruning.

    There is some debate over the pruning of vallis. I have often read that cutting mid leaf can result in brown tips followed by deterioration of the leaf. I have not had this problem myself and i do feel that as long as you use scarp scissors which don't crush the leaf then you can get away with it for a while. I always cut at a 45 degree angle so the cut leaf blends in with the uncut leaves next to it after pruning. You will however get to the point where it is taking over and needs thinning out. Remove whole plants by cutting the runners each side of the roots and removing whole plants.

    Maintaining substrate

    Gravel
    Depending on your foreground design you may or may not be able to access this. we have already covered gravel maintenance under carpeting plants above so i wont repeat myself. If you do have open gravel anywhere in the tank vacuum as usual but don't get too close to the roots of large plants or you may damage them with your prodding and poking.

    Sand
    If like me you have an open sand foreground (ideal for corys and plecs) you can vacuum fully and indeed you should on a weekly basis. Sand compacts over time allowing no circulation of the substrate trapping toxic gasses in the process, if not disturbed these can build up and start to cause problems with plant and (more importantly) fish health. If you do not use a vacuum and opt for a syphon tube then use a tool (i use a chopstick) to stir the sand and release the gas. You will see bubbles when you do this accompanied by a slight smell of rotten eggs (Hydrogen sulphide) As long as this is minimal do not worry. Particular areas where this is most common is beneath rocks and wood so be sure to gently disturb the sand under them to minimise this.

    pfk15.jpg

    You will notice that the most stunning planted aquascapes you see in PFK and on the web all have perfect plants with seemingly no imperfections. I often thought their high budget setups and sheer skill with fertilisation and propagation were responsible for perfect plants, however the fact is that most of them are using the same equipment as you they just know how to get the most out of their plant collection through care and attention. The good news is everyone can do it, you included.

    I hope this is of some use and helps someone along their way into the world of planted aquariums. Look after your plants and they will go from strength to strength.
     
  2. Steve Smith

    Steve Smith Member

    Messages:
    4,430
    Location:
    Leamington Spa, UK.
    Looks like a great guide! Can't wait to read it properly!
     
  3. Keith

    Keith Member

    Messages:
    27
    Thanks for that. As a newby I really appreciate it.
     
  4. Dan Crawford

    Dan Crawford Founder Staff Member

    Messages:
    3,266
    Location:
    Daventry, Northants
    What a cracking artical! Fantastic job James. :D
     
  5. Themuleous

    Themuleous Member

    Messages:
    4,126
    Location:
    Aston, Oxfordshire
    Superb Jim, excellent job, I've duly printed it and added it to my library.

    Sam
     
  6. James Flexton

    James Flexton Member

    Messages:
    358
    Location:
    Stotfold, Herts/Beds
    glad you like it i put pen to paper and it all spilled out on the page. it wasn't meant to be that long but cant think of anything worth leaving out so i left it as it was.

    not sure what the plans are for pinned threads on here but that was the general idea if the mods agree so it doesn't get lost down the pile.

    James

    ps. anyone disagree with any of it. i dont want to assume my way is always corect so please let me know if you have a better suggestion for any part and i will edit the original post.
     
  7. Matt Holbrook-Bull

    Matt Holbrook-Bull Founder

    Messages:
    963
    Location:
    Dorset, UK
    seriusly good work mate :)

    stickied as requested by George :)
     
  8. James Flexton

    James Flexton Member

    Messages:
    358
    Location:
    Stotfold, Herts/Beds
    great, thanks Matt / George.
     
  9. Steve Smith

    Steve Smith Member

    Messages:
    4,430
    Location:
    Leamington Spa, UK.
    I've read it properly now, and its great mate!
     
  10. ulster exile

    ulster exile Member

    Messages:
    350
    Location:
    Birmingham, UK
    I echo Keith's comments - it's an excellant article to read from the point of view as a n00b.

    You have also eased my mind, because what you described (and illustrated) happening to your riccia happened to my monosolenium after a couple of months of steady growth attached to slate. I presumed I was missing something, but it's great to hear that it's a natural occurance.

    Many, many thanks for a useful article. :D
     
  11. ceg4048

    ceg4048 Expert/Global Moderator Staff Member

    Messages:
    8,937
    Location:
    Chicago, USA
    Top grades James, really well done. Much appreciated!

    Cheers,
     
  12. oldwhitewood

    oldwhitewood Member

    Messages:
    356
    Very good indeed really impressed with it, learnt some stuff too.
     
  13. James Flexton

    James Flexton Member

    Messages:
    358
    Location:
    Stotfold, Herts/Beds
    hi Neil. I'm intrigued - what did you learn? your tank is fantastic and this was aimed at newbies. lol

    i guess nobody knows which bits of their knowledge are basic and which are advanced. it's just a collection of things you have learnt along the way there's always room to add more and this is why i love this place. for example i have trouble getting moss to grow long term in my tanks and after reading your thread you mentioned that mosses like soft water. well as mine is hard as nails that makes perfect sense. Well i'll put it down to that for now anyway, means it's not my fault! lol

    glad you liked..
     
  14. Matt Holbrook-Bull

    Matt Holbrook-Bull Founder

    Messages:
    963
    Location:
    Dorset, UK
    I have the same issues James with java moss not liking my hardish water. it grows, but incredibly slowly. Ive also read recently, in PFK I think it was, that Oto's will eat java fern.. although I cant say ive seen mine doing that, and even if they were appearing to, it would be hard to tell if it wasnt algae they were munching.

    I did find increasing the flow over the moss helped somewhat though. Just a thought.
     
  15. James Flexton

    James Flexton Member

    Messages:
    358
    Location:
    Stotfold, Herts/Beds
    ahh good to know thanks mate. TBH it's more the fact that it positivly refuses to hold onto anything in my tanks. i have used cotton thread, hairnets and on one occasion both and it all ends up in a big mess foating about the tank. even the beautiful piece i pinched from george when he went to the falklands fell apart. did fine for about 6 weeks then just fell off the wood that george had expertly secured it to and floated off. then it just slowly died off. i still find the odd scrap stuck in my plants but nothing that makes me think it is growing, more sustaining itself in little nooks and crannies. none of those have rooted either, even one bit i found stuffed into a crack in one bogwood piece just fell out when i pulled it, no attachment at all and it must have been there for at least 8 months.
     
  16. LondonDragon

    LondonDragon Administrator Staff Member

    Messages:
    10,263
    Location:
    London
    This is a great article, thanks for sharing, congrats :)
     
  17. tanker

    tanker Member

    Messages:
    102
    Location:
    Malaysia
    This is greatly helpful! Especially for noob like me. Thanks James

    Sometimes ago (before i discovered ukaps) the shop guy advised that to trim stem plants, i can actually cut at the base thus leaving the roots still in substrate, trim off the uglier lower parts and then replant. And that was what i did. Now i think it can have some negative implication as the roots rot in the substrate. Bad advise that was?
     
  18. beeky

    beeky Member

    Messages:
    879
    Location:
    Chippenham, Wiltshire
    Depends how vigorous the plant is really and how much you do it. Roots could rot or it could sprout again. If they rot it may be OK and would provide a bit of nutrition for the replanted bit, but do it too much and you could get problems. I'd say cut in half and replant and if you don't want the lower bit pull it up very slowly. The filter should clear any cloudiness away quickly.
     
  19. Themuleous

    Themuleous Member

    Messages:
    4,126
    Location:
    Aston, Oxfordshire
    Tropica recommend cutting the plants off at the base and leaving the roots in the substrate. Certainly for high CEC substrate like tropica, akadama, ADA AS its a good thing (as I understand it). As the rots root they release the nutrients they hold which the substrate holds onto ready for the next set of plants.

    Sam
     
  20. ceg4048

    ceg4048 Expert/Global Moderator Staff Member

    Messages:
    8,937
    Location:
    Chicago, USA
    Decay in the sediment consumes oxygen and gives rise to anaerobic bacteria while suppressing aerobic bacteria. I don't think this is a good trade off at all. There is plenty of organic matter being provided to the sediment from the detritus that settles from the water column as well as organics leached by the leaves. Living roots oxygenate the soil via the plant's transport of O2 to the root from above which support the good bacteria involved in the nitrogen cycle. Dead and decaying roots do just the opposite. I can see no reason at all to leave decaying matter in the soil, at least not in a high tech tank. :wideyed:

    Cheers,
     
    Glenda Steel likes this.

Share This Page

Facebook Page
Twitter Page
  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
    Dismiss Notice