• You are viewing the forum as a Guest, please login (you can use your Facebook, Twitter, Google or Microsoft account to login) or register using this link: Log in or Sign Up

RO unit worth it?

Brad123

Brad123

Member
Joined
24 Jan 2013
Messages
140
Location
Oxfordshire
I live in Oxfordshire lovely hard water is it worth buying a ro unit? I like the idea of 1 but will it help or make things complicated?
 
Brad123 said:
I live in Oxfordshire lovely hard water is it worth buying a ro unit? I like the idea of 1 but will it help or make things complicated?
Click to expand...
I’d recommend to try Spotless Water. I’m personally using it for about 1.5 years, consistent 0 TDS from their hose and haven’t encountered any issues so far. The price depends on the location but in Bournemouth the cost is 1.5p per litre.
PM me if interested. I think if I’d recommend someone we both would get about £20 credit each.
 
My RO unit has dual membrains and has a waste to production ration of around 1.5:1, still some waste but not 90%.

Produces water with tds of 12
 
All depends what fish you’d like to keep, size of the aquarium etc. If you had a Malawi cichlid tank or rainbow fish for example it would be useless. An aquarium with wild caught South American species then it would be a differrent story.

cheers

Conor
 
papa_c said:
My RO unit has dual membrains and has a waste to production ration of around 1.5:1, still some waste but not 90%.

Produces water with tds of 12
Click to expand...
My RO system with a single membrane is claimed to be 1:5 (5 liter of waste to 1 liter of "pure" water) @ 25C (77F) and 60 PSI of water pressure.... However, at lower pressure and lower temperature the efficiency goes way down... right now (spring in Minnesota) I am probably getting somewhere around 1:8 ... in the depth of winter it's more like 1:12... so it really depends. TDS however, is constant... with a brand a new membrane I'm getting 2-3 TDS ... right now my RO water is around 4-5 TDS regardless of water temp.

Cheers,
Michael
 
Last edited:
I would say depends on why you want one? If it’s for plant growth I would say not. I would say much more important is optimising Co2. You will likely use more co2 with harder water but the vast majority of plants won’t care on the hardness of the water.
 
Cheers all for the reply’s. should of explain a bit better was thinking more on the water quality side. To get the right GH and KH is that worth it for the plants.
The tank is only a 65ltr at the moment doing daily water changes(tank 2 weeks).
I work at a power station so can get 0 TDS water but it’s a pain to get home. That’s why I was looking at ro units.
 
Tom Michael said:
I would say depends on why you want one? If it’s for plant growth I would say not. I would say much more important is optimising Co2. You will likely use more co2 with harder water but the vast majority of plants won’t care on the hardness of the water.
Click to expand...
Ok thanks that’s what I was after
Cheer Brad
 
I have a 60L tank which is filled with rainwater. I have 2 20L jugs which I fill either in my garden or at the allotment, to do a 30 - 50% change a week (I don't use CO2, so each jug lasts me a week). My plants do grow pretty well in it, but not as well as tap water and CO2. I use rainwater because I like to keep softwater fish, I have another tank with tapwater and shrimps and the plants grow just as well. If you want a really amazing hightech tank with loads of fancy Dutch-style stems then I think softwater does help. You'd only need 1 big waterbutt to collect enough water weekly for it, if you have a garden and a roof of any kind it's really easy to do!
 
Last edited:
I’d disagree with this a touch, fish do care about water hardness.
Click to expand...

Why just a touch, it's pretty fundamental that water hardness plays a large role in fish health.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Obviously, if you’re trying to breed soft water species it’s important, but otherwise not so much.
 
Obviously, if you’re trying to breed soft water species it’s important, but otherwise not so much.
Click to expand...
There is no way I would keep Dwarf Cichlids from the Amazon Basin at the same water parameters (including water hardness) I used to keep African Rift Lake Cichlids ... That said, most fish, especially fish bred in captivity, have a far higher tolerance to a much wider range of water parameters than most tend to believe. That said, I don't think its distraction from the hobby of fish keeping to at least be in the ballpark of the water parameters found in the fishes natural habitat - and see no reason why the fish would not be better off with that.

Cheers,
Michael
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top