What all in one recipe?

B4M

Member
Joined
24 Sep 2008
Messages
61
Hi,

I'd like to make an EI all in one solution but am confused.

James' very useful site lists the following(http://www.theplantedtank.co.uk/allinone.htm):

PMDD+PO4 formula:
10g Potassium Nitrate
1.0g Potassium Phosphate (monobasic)
4.0g Potassium Sulphate
8.0g Magnesium Sulphate Heptahydrate (Epsom Salts)
6g Aqua Essentials Trace Elements Mix
0.5g E300 Ascorbic Acid
0.2g E202 Potassium Sorbate
500ml distilled water

DIY TPN+
48g Potassium Nitrate
2.2g Potassium Phosphate (monobasic)
17g Magnesium Sulphate Heptahydrate (Epsom Salts)
5g Aqua Essentials Trace Elements Mix
0.5g E300 Ascorbic Acid
0.2g E202 Potassium Sorbate
500ml distilled water

This link then gives instructions for an EI all in one which uses different quantities:
http://ukaps.org/forum/viewtopic.php?f=11&t=2424

The two lists above have more Potassium Nitrate than Magnesium Sulphate but in the excel sheet it calculates 2.5 times more Magnesium Sulphate than Potassium Nitrate. Is this based on true EI rather than PMDD or DIY TPN+?

I could also make a NPK mix and CSM+B as separate mixes but I would prefer to does the same every day: http://ukaps.org/forum/viewtopic.php?f=34&t=1211

Full details of my tank are in my journal but it's heavily planted with injected CO2 to 30 ppm and high lighting. Which of these options would you recommend based on a 50% water change weekly?

Thanks,

B4M
 

ceg4048

Expert/Global Moderator
Staff member
Joined
11 Jul 2007
Messages
8,993
Location
Chicago, USA
Hi,
No one can guarantee which of those recipes will best fit your tank because every tank is different, every bubble rate is different and everyone lighting is different. All these recipes work but all require tweaking to some degree based on how the tank performs. People who have massive biomass + very high lighting and who use very high CO2 levels will find that the standard EI dosing per the dry powder article will work and that the dosages may even need to be increased. Folks who have lower lighting and/or lower biomass and lower Co2 levels will find the DIY TPN+ or the PMDD+PO4 strategy acceptable, but may have to tweak PO4.

My advice would be to pick one dosing strategy and try to become adept at it. Based on your objective of preferring to dose the same amount every day I would say try the DIY TPN+ first and see how that goes. Again you may need to tweak depending on all variables. Keep the tank clean, prune frequently, ensure stable levels of CO2/flow and try to eliminate these as factors in possible algal appearance. If the tank is happy with the dosing plant growth will be good and algae minimal. Make adjustments based on whatever deficiencies appear. Regardless of which method you choose, note that 95% of the time poor CO2 will be your undoing.

Cheers,
 

B4M

Member
Thread starter
Joined
24 Sep 2008
Messages
61
I think I'll give the mix given in the excel EI calculator a go. Ratios seem closer to true EI.
So with a 250L tank to make up 1.5L and I chose to dose 25ml per day which is 175ml a week. The formula is based on dosing 3 times a week so I entered 58.3ml per dose, but I will actually does 25ml daily. Both equate to 175ml per week.

Ingredient Grams
KNO3 87
KH2PO4 25
MgSO4 225
Traces 10.2
Ascorbic Acid 1.5
Potassium Sorbate 0.6

I'll see how this goes and adjust if needed.

B4M
 

Midnight

Member
Joined
2 Sep 2008
Messages
48
Location
North Yorkshire
B4M said:
I'd like to make an EI all in one solution but am confused.

I had the same confusion so emailed James direct. He explained the TPN recipe was really only for information. Neither recipe as I understand it, are subsitutes for E.I. they are more for people like myself whose lifestyle doesn't afford the routine required for E.I.

I know bot-all about this stuff, so decided to just try it with minimal science and see what happens. You can see this at
viewtopic.php?f=11&t=3157
 

B4M

Member
Thread starter
Joined
24 Sep 2008
Messages
61
Thanks Midnight,

I made up the mixture last weekend and have been dosing 25ml per day. As far as I can tell this is close to EI quantities but combined into an all in one and using James' adders to prevent unwanted reactions. So far the liquid has remained a light green with no settlement.

B4M
 

Midnight

Member
Joined
2 Sep 2008
Messages
48
Location
North Yorkshire
B4M said:
I made up the mixture last weekend and have been dosing 25ml per day. As far as I can tell this is close to EI quantities but combined into an all in one ........

I'm using a similar recipe to James' but based on teaspoons and I don't think it's anywhere near E.I. levels. It's difficult for me to get a routine so only change about 30% of the water every now and then.

It would be interesting to see your results. How about adding before and after photos?
 

YzemaN

Member
Joined
6 Nov 2007
Messages
183
Location
Copenhagen
Ooohhh... Someone's using my sheet :D
A word of caution though, the calculations have not been verified and it was doing my head in trying to juggle all the numbers and sub-calculations.
B4M said:
...but in the excel sheet it calculates 2.5 times more Magnesium Sulphate than Potassium Nitrate. Is this based on true EI rather than PMDD or DIY TPN+?
The amounts are based on the UKAPS EI article, but I think MgSO4 should only be about twice the amount of KNO3 , so it seem like there's an error somewhere?
I have made a couple of other sheets and the one I'm using at the moment is super simple; You type in the fractions of a teaspoons per dose of the different salts based on a table with the "standard" tank sizes often mentioned on EI articles (20G, 40G and so on...), then type in the volume of the solution and the dosage and it then gives you the numbers you have to add in teaspoons. A bit more manual work, but at least the calculations were simpler... Perhaps I should edit the original post I made?

I would like to hear how this one works for you, hopefully it won't turn your tank into an algae soup, but there's a fair amount of ferts in the solution, so it's unlikely.
 

ceg4048

Expert/Global Moderator
Staff member
Joined
11 Jul 2007
Messages
8,993
Location
Chicago, USA
Be careful about ratios of this to that. EI is not based on ratios and it certainly does not imply that MgSO4 should be dosed at 2.5 times that of KNO3. That's not written anywhere and if it appears that way, is an illusion. Some folks may not need to use MgSO4 at all. Others using pure RO water may use more. It depends on what's in your tap and how the tank is configured. These numbers are baseline and are used as a reference only. Start with them and make adjustments based on your observations of plant growth and health. Stop worrying about numbers and pay attention to what is happening inside the tank. :idea:

Cheers,
 

Midnight

Member
Joined
2 Sep 2008
Messages
48
Location
North Yorkshire
ceg4048 said:
............... Stop worrying about numbers and pay attention to what is happening inside the tank. :idea:

Cheers,
Yes that's what I have been trying to do. Since beginning my experiments with All-in-one
http://ukaps.org/forum/viewtopic.php?f=11&t=3157
I have added a powerhead and drop checker/KH4 solution based on the advice received and adjusted the dosing and strength based on what I see.
 

B4M

Member
Thread starter
Joined
24 Sep 2008
Messages
61
YzemaN said:
Ooohhh... Someone's using my sheet :D
Thanks for taking the time to develop it.
YzemaN said:
I would like to hear how this one works for you, hopefully it won't turn your tank into an algae soup, but there's a fair amount of ferts in the solution, so it's unlikely.

I've almost finished the first 1 litre of all in one and the tanks looking healthy. I'm trying to follow Clive's advice that it's not about the exact numbers and make adjustments according to what the tank tells me. After the first 500ml I still had some Green Spot Algae so I increased the Potassium Phosphate in the remainder. The GSA has reduced but that may also be down to me increasing the flow.

The spreadsheet is useful for someone starting out as it gives a baseline. The daily dosing of a single mixture suits me as their less to remember.

B4M
 
Similar threads

Similar threads

Top