• You are viewing the forum as a Guest, please login (you can use your Facebook, Twitter, Google or Microsoft account to login) or register using this link: Log in or Sign Up

Journal Biotope of Chorhun river (Crimea, Ukraine)

Total disappointment by the AGA IAC 2024 results in the Biotope category.
Feeling humiliated 😥
 
Total disappointment by the AGA IAC 2024 results in the Biotope category.
Feeling humiliated 😥
I’m sure it’s still very beautiful, I’ve been really looking forward to seeing it - please do share some photos!!

You are scaping against the odds in a way which I imagine almost no other competitor is, don’t feel humiliated or defeated! Whatever the score I know it will still be a fabulous tank.
 
Total disappointment by the AGA IAC 2024 results in the Biotope category.
Feeling humiliated 😥
I would not feel that way, it's just the way contests go ,judging often reflects what's a judges favourite rather than than anything else. Often l see IAPLC entries in the hundreds and wonder why they are not higherly rated. Sometimes the beauty of a entry or the region accuracy clashes with the technical difficulty. Just my thoughts.
 
I would not feel that way, it's just the way contests go ,judging often reflects what's a judges favourite rather than than anything else. Often l see IAPLC entries in the hundreds and wonder why they are not higherly rated. Sometimes the beauty of a entry or the region accuracy clashes with the technical difficulty. Just my thoughts.

Well said. You have a great tank and should be proud.
 
Thank you everybody here for your kind words and support!

Many aquarists wrongly understand what the biotope aquarium is and set up aquascapes that replicate the above water side of the Earth though the underwater world is different. The majority of contestants is engaged in the aquarium business, they’ve abandoned chances to win the Amano’s IAPLC and come to biotopes to win at least there…
Every year judges are to choose between biotopes and aquascapes in the biotope category. This year they voted for aquascapes. And this fact caused my bitter feelings that I shared with you…

Though the organizing team of the AGA IAC hasn’t published all submissions yet, I’m pretty sure my entry was disqualified. I didn’t have any illusions or hopes about it.
I raised a serious problem that is now slowing down the biotope aquaristics but its solution requires serious changes in our understanding of the concept itself.
I still hope the judges had enough courage to admit the problem.

And finally let’s come back to the ground 😉
2025.01.09 – about 3.5 years old without any restarts and after solving only some minor problems. All plants here were planted before 2024 and with no maintenance since the contest shooting in mid December.

_VSH4950.jpg
 
Untill now - no results of the AGA IAC...
After studying the winning submissions I'm almost sure that my submission was disqualified.
But nevertheless despite all the efforts in creation of the complicated self-sufficient ecosystem and putting everything at stake - life still goes on and I have to focus on the future.

Now I'm working on my #warsurvivaldiary and you are welcome to read the first post in this series:


I would be greatly greatful if you share your own experience in keeping this speciecs (of course if you have any 😉)
 
11 years of the war
3 years of the Ukrainian nation's genocide by the russians

This night I haven't slept, I was standing at the shelter and listening to the Death that was flying over my head. This night it chose other victims.
Russians attacked our critical infrastructure and many of their missiles and drones reached their targets. Russians are making the genocide of the Ukrainian nation and I don't know how long we are able to struggle more.
So now I wish to express my sincere gratitude to all of you who help us stand. You help us stay alive and fight for our future!

I wish to express my deepest condolences to the citizens of the United States: your state is now captured and occupied by the so-callled russia without a single fight. Their spies and agents have taken the control over the White House.
I know, common americans are on our side but you have no more power and rights in your own land and cannot protest against illegal decisions of your maga reign. And from 2025.03.04 the US citizens share responsibility for every murder of every Ukrainian.
2025 03 07 UN voting on Ukraine.jpg
The US refused to recognize the so-called russian federation as aggressor in the UN voting and joined its side in the war.

I have to warn my European colleagues: the war is inevitably coming to your homes, you'd better start preparations for the war ASAP to be ready to take arms and defend homes, also be ready to evacuate your families.

#cancelrussia

You still have chances to prevent the russian invasion in the EU - just cancel everything russian: culture, food, IT, fossil fuels (this one is the hardest to do as your own politicians are financially interested in the opposite).
Stop, end, quit buying, using, supporting everything russian!
Because they use you and your money (direct income, taxes, sensitive data) to kill more people and occupy more lands. Every day of warmth in your house, every russian song in your mediaplayer, every litre of cheap gasoline kill more Ukrainians and bring war closer to your homes. After the fall of Ukraine you will become their next victims.

Now when the US are no more a reliable partner (right now they are violating the Budapest Memorandum and hundreds of other security agreements) please think twice before buying any US produced product as they are reliable partners no more (just remember elon musk's shutdown of Starlink for the AFU in 2022) and may use their products against you. Consider replacing american for European for your own safety:
2025 03 07 buy european.jpg


Juneau is closer to the so-called russia than Kyiv. Remember this

This winter was the worst for my biotope aquarium project. I neither started any new experiment, nor have wish to continue my present projects.
Decline.
Depression.
Decay.
Though my Chorhun river biotope aquarium is feeling great right now, I feel no joy watching it and have no plans to develop it. We together just flow with the water current.
I am afraid to keep responsibility for my pets as every night when going to sleep I am not sure if I be lucky to wake up in the morning.
2025 03 07 _VSH1768 05 09 2024.jpg
Pumpkinseeds are so cute! They are now my absolute favourites

Sorry for this portion of sober reality.
 
Hi all,
I am afraid to keep responsibility for my pets as every night when going to sleep I am not sure if I be lucky to wake up in the morning.
There really isn't anything I can say, other than my (and I'm sure our collective) thoughts are with you in your darkest hour.

Darrel
 
Last edited:
Thanking you for your kind words here and sending my gratitude to everybody who sympathizes and helps us, your help does alot more than you can even imagine!
But I didn't asked for sympathy.

I WARN YOU
 
I lost any hope to get any feedback from the AGA IAC team so I suppose now is the time to start the story of my submission here.

These days I am busy editing the video of my contest sumbmission and until it's ready I share a couple of photos I took on 08.12.2024 during my photo/video shooting for the AGA IAC.

VS138303.jpg

ValeriyShylenko_2024_139302.jpg

nearly 4 years already!
Can you imagine a local European biotope aquarium living successfully for such a long time?!
 
Invasion and occupation. Chorhun River in Aqyar, Crimea, Ukraine



This is my submission to the AGA IAC 2024.

In the wartime I made a tremendous effort to submit my biotope to that contest. Until now they neither posted my result, nor even answered my pledges to provide it.

So here and now I start publishing data on my submission. I cannot wait anymore, I don’t know if I’m lucky to wake up tomorrow (search in the news for Kyiv last night).

Tbh, I don’t know why the AGA team hasn’t published results in the Biotope category. I was worrying if the DOGE fired them all and the association is defunct. But on Thursday they published a new post on their website and fakebook. This bring the conclusion that they are just ignoring me. I’ll be happy to hear back from the AGA IAC though now I realize it’s impossible.

Below is my submission I made on Dec 8, 2024 without any alterings or corrections. Text and photos are the same:

Invasion and occupation.

Chorhun (Chorna) River in Aqyar (Sevastopol), Crimea, Ukraine




Aquarium Volume (L) *

124 (80x50x31 cm)

Lighting

2 LED lamps x20 Wt and 1 10 Wt LED lamp for background

Filtration

internal filter Sunsun JP-023F

Hardscape Materials

oak, hornbeam and willow driftwood, twigs and leaves, Carpathian stones and pebbles

Background

light blue cardboard behind

Substrate

mixture of river sand, pebbles, silt

Plants

Sparganium erectum, Myriophyllum spicatum L, Ceratophyllum demersum, Elodea canadensis (invasive), Potamogeton nodosus, Stuckenia pectinata, Spirogyra sp.

Livestock

Lepomis gibbosus -3 (invasive), Pseudorasbora parva -3 (invasive), Rhodeus amarus -5 (indigenous), Rutilus rutilus -5 (indigenous), Planorbarius corneus -many (indigenous)

ValeriyShylenko_2024_139237.jpg

BIOTOPE ENTRIES ONLY: Additional Information

Invasion and occupation.

Chorhun (Chorna) River in Aqyar (Sevastopol), Crimea, Ukraine


First they invade and conquer your land, then they outlive you and behave as owners and hosts of your land.

The Problem.

Rules of a biotope aquarium contest include a requirement that all inhabitant species must be only indigenous.

This is nice in the ideal world. But in our reality it's sometimes hard to identify the origin of a species you want to add into your contest ecosystem. When you browse a web database like gbif.org or inaturalist.org to find out whether a species is present in your natural biotope, in the results you get all documented occurrences for your coordinates. But this can lead you to disqualification.

Why?

Because chinese sleeper and stone moroko are the most common fish species in the Podillya area where I live, but they are invasive and originate from the Far East, from where both were brought in the mid XX century. So they are not indigenous for biotopically pure aquarium.

But the worst problem of invasive species is that they have already become a vital part of an ecosystem I intend to recreate. So if I exclude stone morokos (as it is required), I will create an inaccurate representation of a local biotope with a questionable vitality.

Now we come to a hard choice between: accurate, healthy biotope and risk of disqualification or unreal outdated one but following all requirements?

As a biotoper I wish to represent the original indigenous biotope but here I have chosen the accurate present biotope to emphasize the problem of invasiveness. And btw invasive species have been living in this area for so long that they are already considered by us as indigenous.

ValeriyShylenko_2024_139302.jpg

The River.

Chorhun is a river in the southwest of the Crimean Peninsula, originates in the Baydar Valley and flows into the Sevastopol Bay in the city of Sevastopol. The length of the river is 41 km, in the Baydar valley on the river there is the Chorhun reservoir, then it flows through the Chornorichensky canyon and flows into the Black Sea in the Inkerman district of Sevastopol. It is the second full-water river of the peninsula.

The nature of the river changes from a rapid mountain stream in the upper part and in the canyon to a wide, slow, full-water river in the Inkerman part before the estuary. It is high-water in the winter-spring period and low-water in the summer-autumn period. In recent years, the river has become extremely low water in the summer, and in 2021 it even dried up in some places.

Protection of the Crimean nature is a huge environmental problem. After the illegal occupation of the peninsula by the russian federation the invaders turned it into their military base. They do not care about ecology at all, they are destroying our unique biotopes when they take water for the needs of their army and fleet.


What is special about my aquarium biotope?

First, it was created in 2021 with last plants added in autumn 2023. This is a long-term healthy ecosystem that accurately represents the natural biotope.

Second, it relies on one-direction water flow system: the water intake is in the right bottom corner, from there water runs through the pipe to the pump at the left side glass and the pump creates powerful current back to the right. All filtering system's elements are hidden behind driftwood and in substrate.

Third, since the russian full scale invasion in 2022 this ecosystem has been coping with constant electricity outages, caused by russian missile attacks on our electricity infrastructure. Proper filtering and lighting setups, selection of inhabitants and constant care help it keep stable balance to survive the wartime and look natural even now.

Fourth, some indigenous fish and plant species were replaced in this biotope ecosystem by invaders just as in the original natural habitat: here I use pumpkinseeds instead of indigenous common perches and ruffes, whom these dangerous invaders ousted in most natural habitats.

Fifth: as the system is mature, the alga cover all possible surfaces: from stones and branches on bottom to side walls of the tank. They contribute to the natural look of the biotope and are vitally important for the ecosystem to survive electricity outages this winter.

ValeriyShylenko_2024_139298.jpg

The problem of invasion ruiningly influences both nature and humans.

Crimean indigenous nature has lost the fight for its habitat, now the Crimean indigenous human ethnoses of Crimean tatars, qaraims, krymchaks are losing their fight against the northeastern invaders.

But we still have the chance...


References:









Original post: https://biotopeaq.wordpress.com/2025/03/23/agaiac/
 
It's a fantastic biotope and project, I love that you are really interogating what a biotope is and what relevance it has to our world today. Is a biotope something which recreates an area of the past, a pristine fantasy of what it once was, or is it something which is accurate to now, which takes into account the layers of human intervention that have redefined nature everywhere? Sadly the reality is our natural waterways have been and continue to be absolutely wrecked across the world in myriad ways. It's important to confront that, not ignore it and pretend it's still as once was. While for a lot of us our aquariums are an escape, they can also be an amazing tool to tell rich stories and histories, and yours is doing that better than any I've ever seen. Sadly it looks like the AGA IAC Judges are more interested in a pretty scene than a moving in-depth investigation of the Chorhun/Chorna River, for artists twas ever thus.

As ever, sending our love and support!!
 
Biotope aquarium of Chorhun river (Crimea, Ukraine)
22.05.2025, last fts:
V13_7589.jpg
This project has crossed its finishing line. Next week I will replace the tank with a bigger one and will try to find inspiration for a new research project.

гussіапs and their allies are desperately making us to surrender, masking it with a term "negotiations". But after defeating Ukraіпе the гussіапs will come to occupy your own homes.
The so-called гussіап fedeгаtioп is a rabid dog that can't be cured. The only way for Europe to avoid your own occupation is to euthanize this rabid dog.

Will you help me find the inspiration?
 
Yesterday I occasionally found a pond with clear water on the outskirts of Vinnytsia. Crystal clear water in my area is almost as rare as good гussiaпs but this phenomenon can be explained: this year the summer is abnormally cold with many rains. This results in colder water and slower algae growth, so the water is surprisingly clear even in the end of June.

DJI_20250625143340_0785_D.jpg

DJI_20250625143227_0780_D.jpg

DJI_20250625144615_0809_D.jpg

My Chorhun river biotope ecosystem has entered the transition mode, I'm planning and preparing to replace the tank, as this one has too many scratches on its walls, and I hope to find and add some extra centimetres to its length (any extra cm3 of volume is good for inhabitants!).

V13_3945.jpg

I wish to express my gratitude to those of you who are still helping us fight - your support is crucial both for our technical resistance and for our mental stability.
Thank you, you make my experiments possible even now!
 
Another sleepless night, another terrible genocidal attack of the so-callled гussіап fedeгаtioп on Ukraine.

This night the гussіапs attacked Vinnytsia, my native city. I spent another sleepless night watching our defenders fight the death that was so carefully brought from гussіа…

The closeness of death made me think more about life and I wrote this story. Now switch on your imagination and read it.


In the middle of the night you suddenly wake up to the strange sound: your neighbour has broken the entrance door of your house, got inside and started to fire at your family from a gun. In the gun you suddenly recognize the one you’ve given to this neighbour several years ago in exchange for his promise to protect you from invaders.

Right now this neighbour has already кіІІеd your parents from your own gun and is attempting to гape your wife. He is threatening you that he кіІІs your children if you try to protect your family and call the police…

Soon the policemen come and ask you to stop resistance, start negotiations and do whatever the criminal wants. But you wish neither die yourself nor sacrifice your wife and children to this rabid neighbour. So the police give you a flyswatter to repel bullets. The criminal is shocked with the determination of the police and starts threatening them…

Soon other neighbours come to the sound of gunshots, see the scene and give your rabid neighbour money to buy more bullets and a new and more reliable gun. The police finally say they are on your side and promise you to bring 17 more flyswatters to repel even more bullets!

This story is weird but it is our present reality if you replace: a rabid neighbour with the so-called гussіап fedeгаtioп, police with the us, flyswatters with air defence and other neighbours with the EU states that are still buying гussіап fossil fuels (Hungary, Slovakia, Austria and partially France, Belgium, the Netherlands) and thus finance further production of their weapons.

On Monday donald trump gave the гussіапs 50 more days to кіІІ more Ukrainians and this night my native city was under just another terrible гussіап attack.

We are to кіІІ the archer and not try to catch his arrows.

The so-called гussіап fedeгаtioп is a rabid dog that cannot be treated (negotiated).

My aquariums? my smart home is taking care of them now...

This is our modern music art: Georgian jazz singer Nino Katamadze (whose homeland - Georgia - is now oссuріеd by the гussіапs) is accompanied by the Ukrainian musician playing the bandura (Ukrainian traditional instrument) on the ruins of the House of officers - iconic sightseeing spot in Vinnytsia where I was happy to work many times before the гussіап full scaІе іпvasiоп...




( facebook.com/share/v/16u5FYMNSo/ )

P.S.: I need no your sympathy. Better spread this post to your friends to open their eyes and start acting to help us solve the problem and keep your own homes safe.
 
I started this journal to share my experience and results of my experiments with you, to boast about my achievements and didn't intend to complain and ask for your sympathy.
The War is correcting my plans every time I want to post here.
Now I'm regaining my courage so let's get back to the journal!
V13_9913.jpg

My biotope aquarium of the Chorhun river (Crimea, Ukraine) is feeling OK.
I removed all watermilfoil plants and allowed water-pineapple to take their place. Now it's grown huge and has given birth to 2 beautiful kid plants.
V13_9925.jpg

Roaches and rudds have overgrown the aquarium volume and soon I plan to return them home, though the war doesn't allow me to move freely to my fishing places and catch new fish species to replace these rudds and roaches...
V13_0077.jpg

And the king of the aquarium - pumpkinseed male
V13_0076.jpg

This fish species is invasive in my land and very dangerous for the native fishes. But these kids are so beautiful and cute, I'm in love with them and wish to keep them as long as possible!

These photos were taken 4-3 hours just before the гussіап drones attack on Vinnytsia. The fishes behaved unusually: they seemed to be afraid, they were mostly hiding in the driftwood decorations and their colours looked dull...
 
Great news!

Tomorrow the fuehrer HітІег will arrive in the US and have negotiations with the US president F. D. Roosevelt about peace in Europe.
Herr HітІег is going to show his kindness and commitment to peace in Europe and even agrees to return the territory of Wales (that he's never occupied) but needs the territories of England, Ireland and Scotland in exchange!
The US president Roosevelt has high hopes to make agreements with this beautiful and kind-hearted dictator, sign the ceasefire with him and finally be awarded the Nobel Peace Prize!

Weird, disgusting and outrageous for you, yeah?

This is what the incumbent president of the US is going to feed us. He is wishing to give the гussіапs our Ukrainian territories in exchange for our other Ukrainian territories.
This the US betrayal of Ukraine: they are giving Ukrainian lands and sacrificing the lives of Ukrainians for your temporary peace.
If you think that the гussіапs are able to fulfil any of their agreements, here is the list of agreeement they signed with Ukraine to recognize the territory and borders of Ukraine. And breached in 2014
Crimea is Ukraine

ГUSSІАПS ARE UNABLE TO FULFIL ANYTHING THEY PROMISE AND SIGN.

The only way to properly "negotiate" is to arrest vladimir putin immediately as this international criminal enters the American land, and bring him to the International Criminal Court.
DJI_20250722121818_0841_D.jpg

Thank you for your sympathy and support and now let's get back to the journal!


These days I'm in the fields performing researches of some gorgeous rivers in my region.
This is the river Buher near the town Lityn, close to Vinnytsia
DJI_20250722113722_0813_D.jpg


DJI_20250722110529_0779_D.jpg

DJI_20250722124731_0896_D.jpg

I hope to survive the upcoming air attack (that the гussіапs are planning for this weekend) and be able to share with you the mesmerizing beauty of my local nature

And remember: to win peace one has not to catch arrows but to кіІІ the archer
 
Back
Top